A sump tank is going to always be better than a canister filter because it holds much more media. Re: Sump vs Canister Filter. A canister filter will actually build up more organics than a sump as it is more compact and detritus will constantly build up. I’m not any help on the sump thing but I’m sure the black tower/column thing is called a overflow. Aquarium size up to approx - 350l Pump output approx I/h - 950 Del.head approx Hmax - 2,0m Power consumption - 20W Canister volume - 9l The aquarium I got has the bottom drilled for a sump, but I really don't like to have the overflow box showing in the corner of the tank. Article from . 3k followers. A detailed breakdown of a compare and contrast of canister filters versus a sump and which is best for your tank at home. Lighting. The multi-stage Fluval 307 (appx. They can be loaded with whatever media you choose, and hold much more media than comparable HOB’s. These are the last 2 days test results, Aqueon ProFlex Sump Model 1, 44-55-Gallon. If you don’t have the correct size filter installed in your tank, you’ll have some pretty crummy filtration going on. After weighing these options, I decided to stick with the canister filter setup and just trying a different brand. A sump gives you complete control over your tank, you can store your equipment in there and it gives you a safe space to pour your additives before they reach the display tank. What does everyone think. This has been so frustrating and more than most that my plants melted due to that initial shock they got from the transition from the aquarium to my newly dirted tank. Nitrate 5/10ppm The sump can be a simple single chamber container or a purpose-built tank with multiple chambers that each have a specific purpose. All Other Hang-On-Back (HOB) Filters. AquaClear Intake Cover. Freshwater Aquarium Fish Forum. In the aquarium world, a “sump” refers to an external reservoir that cycles in between the tank and usually holds additional filtration components. Fitting a sump to your aquarium. Especially if I want fish that produce more waste. Estes Marine Sand. Thanks. Air-driven Internal Filters. Member. They have ultra violet bulbs in them. Estes Bits of Walnut Gravel. Dec 26, 2010. Building it myself. Here is what you need to know about installing a canister filter vs a sump. And thank you for the add  I’m fairly new to the hobby and have a loose grip on the basics, I just bought a 75 gallon with a sumpsetup and would love some help. If your ammonia and nitrite levels are ok, then your current canister is doing its job and changing to sump is a waste of … I have been thinking about it and the extra 30 gallons of water could really do some good because I am heavily stocked. Freshwater Tank Equipment. Share it. Saved from . I have a Marineland penguin 350 and am becoming more agitated with it every day, will probably buy a canister. Could someone please help me with the pros and cons of each. However, they do have one a drawback and it's something you may not have thought about until it's too late. Canister filters. Added 6 tetras yesterday and little bit of food, added 3 more tetras and a cory dora today. A canister filter will actually build up more organics than a sump as it is more compact and detritus will constantly build up. Also included was a eheim classic canister (the 350 if not mistaken) Now I only have 7 fish in the tank and the filtration is IMO pretty much borderline and will need to be upgraded before I stock more fish. Check out this video where we discuss that topic. By darkside666, February 1, 2018 in General Aquarium Discussion. HOBs vs Canister Filters. Cascade Canister Filter Series – Best for Larger Fish Tanks on a Budget. For saltwater/marine setups, there can be provision to put a protein skimmer or media reactor. Don’t let anyone try to upsell you on lighting because you are setting up a saltwater aquarium. the 135 was drilled. Personally, I prefer canisters over sumps. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. If there isn’t water getting into the sump, the pump will need to be switched on and off as the sump collects the water. Discuss it. If you don’t have the correct size filter installed in your tank, you’ll have some pretty crummy filtration going on. These small, inexpensive box-like or foam filters are ideal for rearing fry, … Scenario: got given a 4ft tank incl fish and rock etc. So I'd say it'd depend on your fish and plant stocking. The biggest advantage with sump filters over normal canister type filters is they can take an enormous amount of filtration, far more than you would ever be able to get into a canister filter. I’ve had descent luck with canister filters but still have to do water changes. Ask a Question: BriansAquariumCare@Gmail.com. Promote it. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Aquarium Sump Vs Canister Filter What Is An Aquarium Sump? hi, Sump filter better than canister for fresh water aquarium? Still less than my $100 canister. This reduces evaporation and current. It’s a top rated acrylic setup with tons of 5 star reviews (here is link). Setting a sump for your aquarium is costly, but will give you the most benefits in the long run so if you have the chance, you should totally get one. Sumps also keep the surface of the water free of contaminates and keeping water levels stable in the display tank. Home Forums > Aquarium Filtration and Hardware > Filters, Pumps, etc.. > Canister VS. Sump/fuge Discussion in 'Filters, Pumps, etc..' started by 4G1v3N, Jan 16, 2007. I have others that love high current. Nov 20, 2017 - What is better, a Sump or a canister filter? When you do this swordtails and platies can make good tank mates. Do I need to do are wc? Thank you! Is the tank in a cycle? Obviously, you can add a bit more money on for the pumps and media, but it would have still been a lot cheaper than paying £350 for each canister filter. Trickle filters are aquarium filters that remove the water from your fish tank by means of an overflow and allow it to fall through or over filter media in an open tower to be collected in a sump, and then pump the water back into the tank through a spill way or spray bar.. How Does a Trickle Filter Work? What a pain. If yours is drilled I'd do a sump. I have tried my best make a wet/dry or trickle filter tower that seems to be working as planned, and I have the appropriate media in each level (as per DIY fish keeper on YouTube) but I’m not sure on the flow rates for the intake and return.. And I don’t know what this black tower/column thing that is inside of the main tank is called… Please pity the in over her head chick and help me. A sump won't get rid of nitrates, neither will a canister. Need help? Well, if you use a sump you can go crazy on the filtration. Does my electricty bill doubles because of big pump?. My canister filters have always been good to me, but I began to weigh the options between a canister filter vs a sump. You can easily set it up below, beside or above your tank. Canister filters , modules , and wet/dry filters need a pump to push the water upward. Thanks everyone for the input. Read more to make the smart aquarium filter choice. Build Your Own Custom Sump. cube & after a couple weeks took the whole kit & kaboodle off, patched the holes in the tank & gave the sump away.